First Amendment Under Fire: Appeals Court Ruling Sparks Free Speech Concerns

_A federal appeals court decision to revive a lawsuit against a Black Lives Matter activist has raised concerns about the potential erosion of First Amendment rights_

Background of the Case

A three-judge appeals panel in the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals ruled in a 2-1 decision that a police officer's lawsuit against DeRay Mckesson, a prominent Black Lives Matter activist, deserves a jury trial. The case stems from a 2016 protest in Baton Rouge, Louisiana, where officer John Ford was injured by a "rock-like" object thrown by an unknown individual. Mckesson, who organized the protest, has been accused of negligence, despite the lawsuit not suggesting he hurled the object or even knew about it.

Implications of the Decision

The dissenting judge, Carolyn King, warned that the decision "imperils First Amendment liberties," as it potentially makes Mckesson responsible for the actions of others during the protest. Mckesson himself called the lawsuit "ludicrous" and stated that the decision was disappointing not just for him, but also for "every person who cherishes the right to protest.” The American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU), which represents Mckesson, described a previous federal court ruling in his favor as a "crucial win for the First Amendment right to protest."

Reaction and Next Steps

Mckesson's attorneys with the ACLU decried the decision and said they would continue to seek justice. Mckesson argued that the purpose of the lawsuit was not just to silence him, but to make people afraid to show up to protests because they might get sued for someone else's behavior. The majority opinion, written by Judges Edith H. Jones and Andrew Oldham, found that years of back-and-forth in the U.S. legal system were enough, and while it wasn't certain whether Ford would win, he deserved the trial. An attorney for Ford did not immediately respond to a request for comment, and it remains to be seen how the case will proceed.

Top Stories

Recent Articles

More Articles